McMullin Realty logo

Home  /  Blog  /  Sell or rent when posted out

Military moves

Posted Out of Gagetown: Should You Sell or Rent Out Your Home?

Keeping your Gagetown-area home as a rental can build wealth, but it changes your taxes, your relocation benefits and your workload. Here's how to weigh it before you decide.

Short answer

Rent it out only if the numbers still work after the higher property tax, landlord insurance, a property manager and some empty months, and you're comfortable giving up the relocation benefits for selling. If the rent barely covers the mortgage, selling on your posting is usually the safer move. Decide before you sign anything with your relocation provider, because one of the choices can't be undone.

Your property tax goes up

This is the cost most members miss. In New Brunswick, your principal residence gets the Residential Property Tax Credit, so you pay only the municipal rate. Once the home is a rental, it's taxed as non-owner-occupied and you pay the provincial rate too: $0.5617 per $100 of assessed value, on top of the municipal rate.

  • $250,000 assessment: about $1,404 more a year
  • $300,000 assessment: about $1,685 more a year
  • $400,000 assessment: about $2,247 more a year

Owner-occupied homes also have spike protection that limits assessment increases to 10% a year. A rental doesn't. Tell Service New Brunswick when the home stops being your principal residence, and budget for the new bill.

Your relocation benefits change

If you sell on a posting, your Core account can cover real estate commission, legal fees and other selling costs, and Home Equity Assistance can help if you sell at a loss.

If you keep the home, the CAF Relocation Directive (CAFRD 8.2.03) offers the Real Estate Incentive: 80% of the commission that would have been payable on the appraised value, up to $12,000. The rules that matter:

  • The home must be appraised first, and you have 15 working days from receiving the appraisal to elect it.
  • You waive future reimbursement of real estate fees, legal fees and other selling costs for that home. The election is irrevocable.
  • You can't receive both the Real Estate Incentive and TDRA.

So if you rent now and sell in three years, you pay those selling costs yourself. Confirm your own entitlements with Sirva or BGRS before you elect. See how BGRS and Sirva moves work.

Run the real numbers

Start with realistic rent for your area, then subtract:

  • Mortgage payment (tell your lender it will be a rental)
  • Property tax at the non-owner-occupied rate
  • Landlord insurance, which replaces your homeowner policy
  • Property management, if you won't be nearby
  • Repairs and a reserve for big items like a roof or furnace
  • A month or two empty between tenants

If what's left is thin or negative, the home has to grow in value a lot to beat selling now. Rentals near the base can lease quickly around posting season, but every tenant change costs you time and money.

Being a landlord from a distance

New Brunswick's Residential Tenancies Act sets the rules for leases, security deposits, notices and rent increases, and the Residential Tenancies Tribunal handles disputes. If you'll be across the country, a local property manager is usually worth the fee. Someone has to answer the call when the furnace quits in January.

Don't forget income tax

Rent is taxable income, and turning your home into a rental can affect your capital gains exemption when you sell. The CRA has special rules for homes you've moved out of. Talk to an accountant before the first tenant moves in.

When renting makes sense

  • You expect to be posted back to Gagetown and want to move home again.
  • You have strong equity and a low mortgage rate, so rent clearly covers every cost.
  • You want a long-term investment and have a plan for managing it.

If none of those fit, selling during your posting window is usually simpler. My posted-out selling timeline walks through it, and I can give you a free home value estimate so you can compare both paths with real numbers.

General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice. Property tax figures use the 2026 provincial rate for non-owner-occupied residential property; CAFRD details are from the current directive. Confirm your situation with your relocation provider, Service New Brunswick and an accountant.

Talk to Nick

Let's make a plan

Have a question about your own move? Call or text 506-304-9292, or send me a note and I'll reply within one business day.